It seems that one of the major reasons that the other movie studios have not lined up to get their content in the iTunes store is because they want more restrictions placed on the purchased content. Specifically they want the number of devices a movie can be downloaded to to be smaller.
An article at FT.Com states:
The studios – Universal, 20th Century Fox, Paramount and Warner Bros – are in talks with Apple about making their films available for digital download on iTunes. After months of discussion, a sticking point has emerged over the studios’ demand that Apple limit the number of devices that can use a film downloaded from iTunes.
To be completely honest, I hope that Apple does not give into this kind of demand. And if they do, I hope the movie companies will allow us more tech-oriented people to rip our DVDs to our iPods legally.
The way it currently stands is that ripping a DVD you have legally purchased to your iPod is illegal because under the DMCA (Digital Millineum Copyright Act) you can not break the copy protection encryption on a DVD. What this means is that in order to have a movie on your iPod, you have to download a “made for iPod” version of the movie. In other words, you have to buy the movie twice. In my opinion, since I am ripping the movie to go on my iPod for personal viewing, this is not a violation of fair use under the current United States copyright laws and therefore completely legal. So the current copyright laws and the DMCA are in direct contridiction of each other making almost impossible to determine what is actually okay to do and what is not.
As for Apple’s already imposed restrcitions, I think they are some of the most transparent in this DRM world. Apple’s restrictions are more than resonable and to restrict further is only going to encourage people to go elsewhere for their content.
What do you think of this request from the movie studios?
[Technorati Tag: Technology]
[Technorati Tag: Apple]
[Technorati Tag: Movies]
DRM vs. Music Tax
The big talk these days when it comes to internet downloading is music. In fact, it is what started this whole controversy on what exactly is right and wrong in all things “fair use” but little has been said about how other countries are dealing with this, at least when it comes to the normal media outlets. Other countries are coming up with interesting ways to handle this problem that have the probability of making it to our shores (United States for those that do not know where I’m from). In this week’s commentary article we are going to look at one of the alternative methods being applied to handle the piracy and “fair use” concepts and the pros and cons. Continue reading →